Measuring and characterizing generalization in deep reinforcement learning

Citations Over TimeTop 17% of 2021 papers

Abstract

Abstract Deep reinforcement learning (RL) methods have achieved remarkable performance on challenging control tasks. Observations of the resulting behavior give the impression that the agent has constructed a generalized representation that supports insightful action decisions. We re‐examine what is meant by generalization in RL, and propose several definitions based on an agent's performance in on‐policy, off‐policy, and unreachable states. We propose a set of practical methods for evaluating agents with these definitions of generalization. We demonstrate these techniques on a common benchmark task for deep RL, and we show that the learned networks make poor decisions for states that differ only slightly from on‐policy states, even though those states are not selected adversarially. We focus our analyses on the deep Q‐networks (DQNs) that kicked off the modern era of deep RL. Taken together, these results call into question the extent to which DQNs learn generalized representations, and suggest that more experimentation and analysis is necessary before claims of representation learning can be supported.

Related Papers

• → Human-level control through deep reinforcement learning(2015)29,167 cited
• → Reinforcement Learning: An Introduction(2005)25,702 cited
• Learning What to Attend to: Using bisimulation metrics to explore and improve upon what a deep reinforcement learning agent learns(2020)