The role of psychological testing in forensic assessment.

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 1992 papers

Abstract

Despite the apparent widespread use of psychological tests in evaluations performed by psychologists to assist legal decision makers, there has been little critical but balanced examination of the appropriate parameters for the forensic use of such tests. The following discussion examines the nature of legal decision making, and concludes that the primary legal criterion for the adminissibility of psychological testing isrelevance to the immediate legal issue or to some underlying psychological construct. Assuming thataccuracy is a more consistent concern for psychologists performing such evaluations, the criticisms of various commentators are discussed. Some criticisms appear appropriate and are incorporated into a set of proposed guidelines for the use of psychological tests in forensic contexts. Other criticisms appear misplaced, however, and the call for a whole sale ban on psychological testing in the forensic context is rejected.

Related Papers

• → Clinical presentation of malingerers diagnosed by experienced forensic psychologists.(1989)106 cited
• → The organization of pretrial forensic evaluation services: A national profile.(1994)50 cited
• → Decision making and examiner bias in forensic expert recommendations for not guilty by reason of insanity.(1989)31 cited
• → Competing ethical paradigms in forensic psychiatry and forensic psychology: Commentary for a special section of legal and criminological psychology(2013)2 cited
• → Mental health professionals in forensic arenas(1997)3 cited