A review of Solvency II: Has it met its objectives?

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 2018 papers

Abstract

Abstract Solvency II is currently one of the most sophisticated insurance regulatory regimes in the world. It is built around the principles of market consistency and embedding strong risk management and governance within insurance companies. For business with long-term guarantees, the original basis produced outcomes that were unacceptable to the member states. The original design was amended through Omnibus II. The working party has looked back at the outcome of the final regulation and comments on how well Solvency II has fared, principally from a UK perspective, relative to its initial goals of improved consumer protection, harmonisation, effective risk management and financial stability. We review Pillar 1’s market consistent valuation (including the risk margin and transitional measures) as well as the capital requirements (including internal models). We look at the impact this has on asset and liability management, pro-cyclicality and product design. We look at Pillars 2 and 3 in respect of the Own Risk and Solvency Assessment, liquidity and disclosure. Finally, we stand back and look at harmonisation and the implications of Brexit. In summary we conclude that Solvency II represents a huge improvement over Solvency I although it has not fully achieved the goals it aspired to. There are acknowledged shortfalls and imperfections where adjustments to Solvency II are likely. There remain other concerns around pro-cyclicality, and the appropriateness of market consistency is still open to criticism. It is hoped that the paper and the discussion that goes with it provide an insight into where Solvency II has taken European Insurance regulation and the directions in which it could evolve.

Related Papers

• → Solvency surveillance and financial crisis: evidence from the Spanish insurance industry(2017)15 cited
• A Study on the Minimum Solvency Capital Requirement of China's Non-life Insurers(2014)
• → Discussion on Corporate Solvency Taking Gree Electric Appliance as an Example(2019)
• → Research on Solvency of ZLCs in 2018(2019)
• Solvency Surveillance and Financial Crisis: Evidence from the Spanish Insurance Industry(2017)