MM/GBSA Binding Energy Prediction on the PDBbind Data Set: Successes, Failures, and Directions for Further Improvement

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 2012 papers

Abstract

We validate an automated implementation of a combined Molecular Mechanics/Generalized Born Surface Area (MM/GBSA) method (VSGB 2.0 energy model) on a large and diverse selection of protein-ligand complexes (855 complexes). Although this data set is diverse with respect to both protein families and ligands, after carefully removing flawed structures, a significant correlation (R(2) = 0.63) between calculated and experimental binding affinities is obtained. Consistent explanations for "outlier" complexes are found. Visual analysis of the crystal structures and recourse to the original literature reveal that neglect of explicit solvent, ligand strain, and entropy contribute to the under- and overestimation of computed affinities. The limits of the Molecular Mechanics/Implicit Solvent approach to accurately estimate protein-ligand binding affinities is discussed as is the influence of the quality of protein-ligand complexes on computed free energy binding values.

Related Papers

• → A reference scale of cucurbit[7]uril binding affinities(2021)39 cited
• → Unveiling the novel characteristics of IGPD polymer and inhibitors binding affinities using 12-6-4 LJ-type nonbonded Mn2+ model(2020)5 cited
• → A set of robust fluorescent peptide probes for quantification of Cu(ii) binding affinities in the micromolar to femtomolar range(2015)23 cited
• → The shielding effect of metal complexes on the binding affinities of ligands to metalloproteins(2018)6 cited
• → Synthesis and binding studies of carboxylate binding pocket analogs of vancomycin(2000)15 cited