To reappraise or not to reappraise? Emotion regulation choice and cognitive energetics.

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 2018 papers

Abstract

Research shows that cognitive reappraisal is an effective emotion regulation (ER) strategy that often has clear benefits. Yet, surprisingly, recent findings demonstrate that people use cognitive reappraisal less frequently than might be expected (Suri, Whittaker, & Gross, 2015). We employ cognitive energetics theory (CET) to explain this puzzling behavior. CET posits that the likelihood of launching any cognitive process is a function of two opposing forces: the driving force (i.e., the motivation to launch the process) and the restraining force (i.e., task difficulty). We thus hypothesized that people choose to use cognitive reappraisal relatively rarely because of the difficulty of implementing it. We also postulated that the decision to reappraise (or not) does not simply depend on stimuli emotional intensity because the latter is associated with both the driving and the restraining forces. In support of our hypotheses, we found that when the images' emotional intensity posed difficulty for reappraisal (i.e., highly intense images), reducing this difficulty by asking participants to merely predict others' (Study 1) or their own choices (Study 2) increased reappraisal choice. Finally, in Study 3, we show that a relatively easy to implement reappraisal strategy was chosen more often than the more difficult one for high (but not low) intensity images. These findings illustrate the relevance of a CET-based motivational analysis to emotion regulation choice. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).

Related Papers

• → Incremental theories of emotion across time: Temporal dynamics and correlates of change.(2020)17 cited
• → An event-related potential investigation of distanced self-talk: Replication and comparison to detached reappraisal(2022)5 cited
• → Successful implementation of cognitive reappraisal: effects of habit and situational factors(2022)6 cited
• → Do generation and regulation of emotions interact? Examination of their relationships in young adults(2017)4 cited
• → Supplemental Material for Cognitive Appraisal Contributes to Feeling Generation Through Emotional Evidence Accumulation Rate: Evidence From Instructed Fictional Reappraisal(2021)