Generic solutions for data‐limited fishery assessments are not so simple

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 2018 papers

Abstract

Abstract The majority of the world's fisheries, by number, are data‐poor/limited, and there is a growing body of literature pertaining to approaches to estimate data‐limited stock status. There are at least two drivers for assessing the status of data‐limited fisheries. The first is to try to understand and report on the global or regional status of fisheries across many stocks. The second is to attempt to assess individual data‐limited stocks, for status reporting and/or guiding management decisions. These drivers have led to attempts to find simple, generic, low‐cost solutions, including the broad application of generically parameterised models, and the blanket application of a single, or limited number of possible, analytical approach(es). It is unclear that generic methods function as intended, especially when taken out of their original design context or used without care. If the intention is to resolve individual stock status for the purposes of management, there is concern with the indiscriminate application of a single method to a suite of stocks irrespective of the particular circumstances of each. We examine why caution needs to be exercised, and provide guidance on the appropriate application of data‐limited assessment methods ( DLM s). We recommend: (a) obtaining better data, (b) using care in acknowledging and interpreting uncertainties in the results of DLM s, (c) embedding DLM s in harvest strategies that are robust to the higher levels of uncertainty in the output of DLM s by including precautionary management measures or buffers and (d) selecting and applying DLM s appropriate to specific species’ and fisheries’ data and context.

Related Papers

• → Estimating natural mortality within a fisheries stock assessment model: An evaluation using simulation analysis based on twelve stock assessments(2011)143 cited
• Stock assessment for fishery management - A framework guide to the stock assessment tools of the Fisheries Management Science Programme (FMSP)(2006)
• → Estimating uncertainty of data limited stock assessments(2016)27 cited
• → An Applied Framework for Incorporating Multiple Sources of Uncertainty in Fisheries Stock Assessments(2016)19 cited
• → How many of Australia's stock assessments can be conducted using stock assessment packages?(2016)10 cited