Making the Black Box More Transparent: Understanding the Physical Implications of Machine Learning

Citations Over TimeTop 1% of 2019 papers

Abstract

Abstract This paper synthesizes multiple methods for machine learning (ML) model interpretation and visualization (MIV) focusing on meteorological applications. ML has recently exploded in popularity in many fields, including meteorology. Although ML has been successful in meteorology, it has not been as widely accepted, primarily due to the perception that ML models are “black boxes,” meaning the ML methods are thought to take inputs and provide outputs but not to yield physically interpretable information to the user. This paper introduces and demonstrates multiple MIV techniques for both traditional ML and deep learning, to enable meteorologists to understand what ML models have learned. We discuss permutation-based predictor importance, forward and backward selection, saliency maps, class-activation maps, backward optimization, and novelty detection. We apply these methods at multiple spatiotemporal scales to tornado, hail, winter precipitation type, and convective-storm mode. By analyzing such a wide variety of applications, we intend for this work to demystify the black box of ML, offer insight in applying MIV techniques, and serve as a MIV toolbox for meteorologists and other physical scientists.

Related Papers

• → Understanding Novelty in Organizations(2017)12 cited
• → Tolkku - a toolbox for decision support from condition monitoring data(2012)4 cited
• A tentative talk on the similarities and differences on "novelty" between science and technology checking novelty and patent novelty search(2010)
• → PyPerC: Python toolbox for perceptual computing(2018)
• Toolbox Improving Design Mechanical Tool in Workshop(2011)