Changing Organizational Designs and Performance Frontiers

Citations Over TimeTop 10% of 2011 papers

Abstract

This paper develops and tests a multilevel organizational contingency theory for designing headquarters–subsidiary relations. We use frontier analysis to overcome problems that have hampered advancements in organizational contingency theory in general and headquarters–subsidiary relationships in particular. Based on a longitudinal study of a large medical group practice of 32 local community clinics, we compute the relative distance of clinics from a best-performance frontier, determine what proportions of changes in clinic performance are due to factors that are endogenous or exogenous to the clinics, and examine the organizational factors that may explain these performance changes. We find that uniform headquarters policies have differing effects on the performance of subsidiary units, benefiting some and hindering others through no fault of their own. We also find significant performance volatility with different types of unit designs, suggesting the need to examine the risks of changing organization designs.

Related Papers

• Organization theory: Structure, design and applications(1987)
• → An Efficient Frontier in Organization Design: Organizational Structure as a Determinant of Exploration and Exploitation(2012)181 cited
• → Cascading Organizational Change(2003)160 cited
• → The corporate headquarters in organization design theory: an organizational economics perspective(2019)15 cited
• → Organizational Theory and Its Inspiration(2023)