The Effect of Open Access on Citation Impact: A Comparison Study Based on Web Citation Analysis

Citations Over TimeTop 12% of 2006 papers

Abstract

The academic impact advantage of Open Access (OA) is a prominent topic of debate in the library and publishing communities. Web citations have been proposed as comparable to, even replacements for, bibliographic citations in assessing the academic impact of journals. In our study, we compare Web citations to articles in an OA journal, the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication (JCMC), and a traditional access journal, New Media & Society (NMS), in the communication discipline. Web citation counts for JCMC are significantly higher than those for NMS. Furthermore, JCMC receives significantly higher Web citations from the formal scholarly publications posted on the Web than NMS does. The types of Web citations for journal articles were also examined. In the Web context, the impact of a journal can be assessed using more than one type of source: citations from scholarly articles, teaching materials and non-authoritative documents. The OA journal has higher percentages of citations from the third type, which suggests that, in addition to the research community, the impact advantage of open access is also detectable among ordinary users participating in Web-based academic communication. Moreover, our study also proves that the OA journal has impact advantage in developing countries. Compared with NMS, JCMC has more Web citations from developing countries.

Related Papers

• → Using the Web for research evaluation: The Integrated Online Impact indicator(2009)70 cited
• → Effects of open access and articles-in-press mechanisms on publishing lag and first-citation speed: a case on energy and fuels journals(2021)22 cited
• → Tracking Scholarly Publishing of Hospitals Using MEDLINE, Scopus, WoS and Google Scholar(2017)9 cited
• → Analyzing the Factors Influencing the Waiting Time to First Citation and Long-Term Impact of Publications(2020)3 cited
• → Article level metrics: a look beyond the journal impact factor(2015)