Comparison of novel wearable cardiac monitors to yield accurate exercising ECG and heart rate data in horses

Citations Over Time

Abstract

Exercise associated deaths (EADs) in horses are a problem for the equestrian industry. Sudden death (SD) is responsible for approximately 20% of EADs. The underlying cause of SD is suspected to be cardiovascular disease but often cannot be determined post-mortem. User-friendly cardiac monitors are needed for large scale investigations of arrhythmias associated with SD in horses. We hypothesised that novel wearable devices would provide exercising electrocardiograms (ECGs) of sufficient diagnostic quality for this purpose. Diagnostic quality of ECGs generated by two wearable devices (W2nd ™ and Polar Equine ™ ) were compared to simultaneous recordings with a telemetry unit (Televet ™ ) in 5 Thoroughbreds completing 43 separate submaximal exercise tests on a high-speed treadmill. Maximal heart rate (HR max ) generated by mobile applications (HR maxapp ), HR max after manual correction (HR maxcorr ), percentage of diagnostic ECGs (%diag) at the gallop, and overall quality assessed by visual analogue scale (VAS) were assessed by a blinded observer. HR maxcorr did not differ significantly between groups. HR maxapp was significantly lower for W2nd (166.8/min, 95% confidence interval (CI): 160.5-173.1/min) but did not differ significantly between Televet (178.8/min 95% CI: 165.8-191.1/min) and Polar (181.3/min, 95% CI: 174.5-188.1/min). HR maxcorr was accurate and precise in all runs. HR maxapp was within a priori limits of agreement in 16/23 W2nd and 18/19 Polar recordings. %diag was significantly lower (77.1%, 95% CI: 67.4-86.8) for W2nd than Polar (100%, 95% CI: 89.9-110.3). VAS was lower for W2nd (46.2, 95% CI: 35.5-57.0) than Polar (90.6, 25% CI: 79.4-101.9). In conclusion, wearable devices appear to be promising tools for investigation of equine exercising arrhythmias in large-scale studies.

Related Papers

• → The Visual Analog Scale for Pain(2001)447 cited
• → Minimal important change for the visual analogue scale foot and ankle (VAS-FA)(2020)21 cited
• → Usefulness of visual analog scale for evaluation of the severity and degree of symptoms in childhood allergic rhinitis(2016)1 cited
• → The Effect of Initial Visual Analog Scale Score on Results in Cervical Laser Discectomy(2021)
• → Googleフォームに実装可能なOnline-Based Visual Analogue Scale（O-VAS）の開発(2021)